Posts Tagged ‘analysis’

What Is Value Chain Analysis?

Thursday, December 2nd, 2010

What is value chain analysis?

The value chain, also known as value chain analysis, is a concept from business management that was first described and popularized by Michael Porter in his 1985 best-seller, Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. It is an approach for breaking down the sequence (chain) of business functions into the strategically relevant activities through which value is added by the business. The objective is to identify the behaviour of costs and the areas for differentiation.

It can be conducted at the firm level (internal value chain) or at an industry level (industry value chain). For a vertically integrated business the internal and industry values chains are almost the same.

The industry value chain

The industry value chain is composed of all the value-creating activities within the industry, beginning with raw materials, and ending with the completed product delivered to the customer.

So an example the chemical industry value chain may look like:

  • Raw minerals (e.g. oil, gas, air, water)
  • Basic chemicals production (e.g. inorganics and organics such e.g. ammonia, salts, benzene)
  • Chemical processing
  • Advanced chemicals production (fertilizers, industrial chemicals, plastics)
  • Advanced processing and technology (speciality chemicals, consumer care products, life science)
  • Consumer

The objective of industry value chain analysis is to work out how your part in the industry value chain fits in with your suppliers and customers value chains.

The internal value chain

The internal value chain of a business consists of all physically and technologically distinct activities within the firm that add value to the customer’s experience. The key to this is understanding the activities that create a competitive advantage, and then managing those activities better than other companies in the industry.

Porter (1985) suggested that business activities can fall into two headings: primary activities, those that are directly involved with the physical creation and delivery of the product or service; and support activities, which feed both into primary activities and into each other. Support activities (e.g., human resource management, technology development) are not directly involved in production, but have the potential to increase effectiveness and efficiency.

Porter’s generic value chain looks like the following:

Primary activities consist of:

  1. Inbound Logistics – the receiving and warehousing of raw materials, and their distribution to manufacturing as they are required
  2. Operations – the processes of transforming inputs into finished products and services.
  3. Outbound Logistics – the warehousing and distribution of finished goods.
  4. Marketing & Sales – the identification of customer needs and the generation of sales.
  5. Service – the support of customers after the products and services are sold to them.

Support activities consist of:

  1. Organizational infrastructure – support systems and functions, such as finance, planning, quality control, and general senior management.
  2. Human resource management - activities concerned with recruiting, developing, motivating, and rewarding the workforce of the organization.
  3. Technology development – managing information processing and the development and protection of “knowledge” in the organization.
  4. Procurement – how resources are acquired for the organization (e.g., sourcing and negotiating with suppliers).

The internal value chain model is a useful analysis tool for defining a firm’s core competencies and the activities in which it can pursue a competitive advantage as follows:

  • Cost advantage: by better understanding costs and squeezing them out of the value-adding activities.
  • Differentiation: by focusing on those activities associated with core competencies and capabilities in order to perform them better than do competitors.

The hard part is actually doing this for you company and there are not that many examples available. In my next post I will be going through an example step-by-step to get an idea of what a value chain looks like in practice.

Estimating – The Lost Art

Monday, March 23rd, 2009

Estimating seems to be a lost art, it is one of the most important skills you can learn as it is one of the key factors in job profitability. If you do not get your estimate right and you have a fixed quote, you can literally end up out of pocket. If there is a big overrun then it can affect your reputation.

Estimating improves with experience and I am always calibrating my estimations at the project debrief. Also the more estimates you do the more you can see patterns and be able to increase the tolerance in your estimating.

Methods of estimating

There are many different methods of estimating, I have outlined a few that I have come across in different organisations. There is no right and wrong method, and the method used will depend on the project’s size and scope.

1. Top down estimating

This is used when there is limited amount of detailed information about the project, for example in the early phase of a project. Top down takes the whole view of the project. generally working by analogy with other similar projects that have accurate historical information.

2. Bottom up estimating

This works by breaking the project up into small pieces and estimating each individual piece. The people who provide the bottom up estimates are usually the ones that will perform the work. It is usually driven by the work breakdown schedule or task list. Bottom up estimating tends to underestimate as the inter-task elements or glue tasks, such as project management tend to get forgotten.

3. Comparative or analogous estimating

This is another method where estimates are driven by analogy with the details of previous projects. It is frequently used to estimate project costs when there is little detailed information about a project (early phases).

4. Delphi Method

Uses a number of different estimates from project staff and then uses a weighted average. It uses expert opinion of a group to arrive at a consensus. The process is iterative and anonymous. After each person has estimated the coordinator gathers the estimates and re-distributes them. Each person then re-estimates based on these new guidelines and the process stops when a consensus has been reached.

5. Parametric estimates

Uses statistical models obtained from historical analyses of cost, effort or material data. This is mostly used in life cycle costing to see the costs over the lifetime of the product. These costs look accurate so can be dangerous.

6. Three point estimate method

Uses an optimistic (O), most likely (ML) and pessimistic (P) value of time and cost. To get the planning value (PV) from the three point estimate with the following formula: PV = (O + 4ML + P) / 6. The multiple of 4 acts to weight the figure in favour of the most likely.

Remember that estimates should be reviewed regularly throughout the project.

Know Your Client

Sunday, March 8th, 2009

Do you really know who your client is?
Do you know their management and reporting structure?
Have you analysed the key stakeholders in the project?

If you have answered yes to all of these then well done, if not you could be in for a big surprise when you come to sign off the project. Many a project has failed due to key stakeholders wading in at the end of a project, if you have not engaged with them at all key decision gates.

Who is your client?

We define the client as the main point of contact within the company you are working with. Your client is not always a senior stakeholder or project sponsor. You need to identify who has the authority to sign the project off in your client’s organisation.

Project sponsor

The project sponsor is the person who owns the business case for the project, and is responsible for delivering the project benefits to the organisation. The project sponsor is the most important person on the project, so you must identify and engage with them at all times.

Analyse project stakeholders

Stakeholders are people with a vested interest in the project, and a cross section of stakeholders usually sit on the project steering committee with the project sponsor.

Not all stakeholders are made equal, so you need to rank the stakeholders with the following criteria:

  • How much influence they have in the organisation
  • How much interest they have in the project

The most important stakeholders are those with a lot of influence and a lot of interest in the project.

Stakeholders have a huge impact on a project, so you need to know who the key influencers are and who calls the shots.

Conclusion

Knowing your client affects the way you communicate and how the project is run, and ultimately affects the success or failure of the project.

We make sure that at the start of every project we have only one main point of contact (client), who calls the shots, and we make sure that we communicate and collaborate with the key statkeholders. Otherwise your project is doomed to fail.